monthly international bank transfer inquiry
though i've read a few posts on here about international bank transfers, i'm yet to find a satisfactory response. I was just wondering what bank is the best for expats in Beijing in terms of monthly international money transfer. I soon will start working in china, but i have some financial obligations in Canada, mostly student loans. So i was wondering how i could send money to my Canadian bank account every month while avoiding high transaction fees.




gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Even sending a minimal amount will cost you about $25 in fees on this side plus whatever your bank(s) in Canada charge.
Cheapest option is to buy a cashier's check (demand draft) in C$ from Bank of China and then send that back home for deposit into your bank account. Total cost including postage is about 70 RMB.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
adecrown
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
alright,
so does this mean i can write a cheque to myself everymonth? how does this work? Please enlighten me on this matter
Thank You
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
You take your RMB or US$ into Bank of China and tell them you want to buy a demand draft (hui piao). You tell them who to make the draft payable to and what currency and the amount.
They issue you the draft (check) and you send it to your bank for deposit. Fee is 50 RMB.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
liveforfood
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
gdbill,
What is the limit for one of these demand deposits? Does the daily $500 limit apply?
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Not sure what you mean by time limit.
It takes about 20 minutes for the Bank of China clerk to issue the draft. You need to deposit the draft or cash it within one year.
The limit would apply, but what you can do is buy $500 today, tomorrow and the next day and let the US$ sit in your account. Then go in the next day and with that money buy a $1500 draft.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
liveforfood
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Thanks gdbill,
I actually wrote limit, not time limit. And though I obviously didn't make myself clear enough - I was referring to the $500 daily limit .... you never the less addressed and answered the question anyway. Thanks
So further to that, once a person has accumulated the total amount of foreign money (say $10,000 USD) at $500 per day, how do they best send that already exchanged foreign currency?
Thanks again
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Ok, let's say you've got $10,000 and you want to get that money back home. I see three ways:
1. Stuff the cash in your pockets and fly home with it.
Factoring in airfare, expenses and lost time, this might not be the best way.
2. Wire it to your bank back home. This can take two or three days for the money to arrive and will cost you at least 500 RMB.
3. Buy a demand draft for $10,000 at Bank of China. A demand draft is nothing other than a cashier's check in the currency of your choice. If, for example, the money's ultimate destination is the US, then you get a demand draft in US$ payable on Bank of China's New York Branch.
You mail that demand draft (aka cashier's check / aka check) to your bank and it is deposited into your account. The only fees you pay are about 100 RMB to Bank of China to buy the check and postage -- about 20 RMB -- to mail it home to your bank. The downside is it takes a week or two to get there.
Now, what can make the demand draft extremely attractive -- and much better than a wire in every aspect -- is if your bank has a feature called "Deposit@Home" or something similar. My bank in the US has that and all I do is buy the check at Bank of China, hook up my scanner to my PC, endorse the check, log onto my bank's online banking platform and go through the bank's 5-minute process which involves scanning the check. Immediately the funds are sitting in my bank account ready to spend.
You then save the check for 30 days in case there are problems and after 30 days you destroy the check.
I have done this dozens of times and for about 100 RMB you can move $10,000 into your US bank account in under 10 minutes.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
liveforfood
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Thanks gdbill,
Your description begs one more question .... does it have to go to one's own outside account, or could a person direct one of these demand drafts to wards another person or organization's bank account?
Thanks again.
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
It can go anywhere you'd like.
When you purchase the check in addition to the amount and currency, Bank of China will ask you who to make it payable to. You can tell them either to make you the payee or anybody else that you wish.
If using the mail, you mail the draft to the payee. However, if you are using the Deposit@Home function only the payee can use it to deposit the check into their account.
For example, if I am the payee (Thankyouverymuch!!), I can take the draft, endorse it and then use my computer and scanner to have the check deposited into my account using Deposit@Home or some similar service. If I am the payee, you cannot deposit the check into your own account.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
liveforfood
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
and as my Chinese is spotty at best, what is the Chinese name for these Demand Deposits?
Thanks,
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Not demand deposit. It's a demand draft. In Chinese they are called "hui piao".
If they do not understand, get the standard wire transfer form and look at the very top. One or two lines down there will be a row of check boxes for the type of remittance you want to send. One is labeled "T/T" for a normal wire transfer and another is "D/D" for demand draft.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
adecrown
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
thank you so much!
this has been very helpful and i'm sure very useful.
but just one question if you don't mind, do i have to go to Bank of China, can i just do it with China Construction Bank since that is the bank i use. and i suppose the bank draft is cheaper than wire transfer
Sciency
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
I use China Construction Bank.
For domestic money transfer, NP.
But don't bother to exchange there. They have this policy of 5000 RMB per day.. So if u want to leave the country for a vaca, better to take ur money out in cash RMB and exchange elsewhere into USD. Unless u feel like going in there every day for a fkn week or more to exchange their under their pissant limit.
Galaxies don't move Sciency. They're in a fixed position.
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
As far as I know, the only two banks that offer demand drafts (i.e. cashier's checks) that are -- and this is VERY important -- drawn directly on a US bank (member of the Federal Reserve) and payable in US$ are bank of China and ICBC.
If you obtain a demand draft that is not payable in US$ and / or not drawn directly on a bank that is a member of the Federal Reserve, it will be considered a "foreign check" by your bank and take about a month or longer to clear and you will be charged check clearance fees -- around $100.
If the bank that sells you a demand draft sells you what is technically known as a money order and not a cashier's check, you will not be able to use a service like Deposit@Home to scan and deposit your item electronically.
I would stick to what is known to work: either BOC or ICBC.
As for cost, a demand draft is anywhere from 50 - 100 RMB. Your cheapest wire transfer is about 200 RMB.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
liveforfood
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Oh this is a US bank only thing. Glad you clarified that gdbill.
What is so special about the US banks?
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
It doesn't have to be for people in the US only.
Bank of China also sells demand drafts payable in Canadian dollars payable through a Canadian bank. They sell demand drafts in pounds sterling payable through a bank in the UK.
As for Deposit@Home services, I don't know if banks in other countries offer that.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
Leor
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Is it possible to get a demand draft in RMB and deposit that into an american bank account? If so is there a limit to the amount of RMB you can get a demand draft for? Also, can you buy the demand draft in US dollars if your chinese bank account only contains RMB or do you have to exchange the currency 500 dollars at a time? If you are a customer with Bank of China can they take the money directly out of your account or do you have to provide them with cash?
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
I've never heard of an RMB demand draft, but even if you could get one it would not be accepted by any US bank. The problem is that the RMB is not a freely convertibly currency so any RMB instrument could not clear through the US banking system.
To buy a US$ demand draft you need to exchange your RMB into US$. You can use the RMB in your account at, per your example, Bank of China, but you need to meet the requirements to buy US$. Without tax receipts and the like, you may be limited to $500 per day.
If limited to $500 per day, you can simply excgange the RMB into US$ today, for example, and leave the US$ you bought in your Bank of China account. Tomorrow buy another $500 ... and so on. When you have accumulated the amount of US$ you think is right, use them to buy a demand draft.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
Monkey King
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Or he can take a Chinese person with him to exchange RMB to USD. Chinese people aren't subject to the same restrictions.
I usually do this myself, it must be quite obvious to the tellers that the Chinese person is my stand-in but there's never been any problem.
"China is a big country, inhabited by many Chinese."
--Charles de Gaulle
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
^
You are definitely correct. That is the easiest way.
It's kind of funny, too, because it is defeating the whole idea of currency restrictions. I can think of dozens of times when staff at the bank have even recommended doing just that.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
English Wang Danny
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
the demand draft sounds great !
do ICBC do this ?
http://mygreenapple.net/page/wenhua/index.php
Monkey King
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Just another one of those rules that everyone involved knowingly ignores!
I think that Chinese nationals are supposed to be limited to exchanging only a certain amount per year--$50,000 or something like that?--but I don't know if they can even track that properly, especially if a person uses different banks.
"China is a big country, inhabited by many Chinese."
--Charles de Gaulle
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Yes, ICBC can. The only two banks that I know of that offer demand drafts are Bank of China and ICBC. The fees are just about the same with eachbank, but what makes ICBC slightly less attractive is that you must go to their main office in Fu Xing Men to buy them. With Bank of China you can go to most of the major branches.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Yes, unless they obtain special permission from the State Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE), they have a hard limit of $50k for buying, selling and overseas remittance.
At one time I also thought like you in that perhaps you can escape the limits by using different banks. Unfortunately, it won't work. Every foreign currency conversion transaction must be conducted using the SAFE system in realtime. Unless the system is on the blink, it will catch you trying to defeat the restrictions.
I was $1,000 short of my $50k limit last week and needed to buy $1500. I went to Bank of China for $1,000 and then ICBC for $500 more and got busted.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
Monkey King
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Really? I'm kind of surprised to hear that.
It's useful intel to know they CAN track it, though, and in real time apparently.
Just means you need to plan ahead a little, I guess. And know more than one Chinese person if you want to exchange lots of $$$...shouldn't be a problem with 1.3billion of them!
"China is a big country, inhabited by many Chinese."
--Charles de Gaulle
Leor
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
Ok I asked my bank in America Bank of America if they would accept a demand draft in RMB and they said that it would be fine. They just exchange the currency when you deposit it at the current rate and it should go into your bank account. Is there some reason why you say that no bank in america will accept a demand draft that is in RMB? Thank you so much. Has anybody ever had a demand draft created in RMB?
admirerdr
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
1. No Bank in CHINA can issue a DEMAND DRAFT in RMB and payable overseas ( say USA / UK etc.)
2. Banks in CHINA may issue a " COC " ( Cashier's order cheque)
or a Bank's Payment Order ( PO ) in RMB but it will be drawn on themselves i.e. PAYABLE in CHINA.
3. What will happen if you deposit this RMB PaymentOrder in your account in an OVERSEAS Bank ( say USA ) ? Most probably, the Bank will not be able to accept it even under " Bills for collection" ( since RMB is not freely convertible currency )
4. A DD ( Demand Draft ) in RMB payable OVERSEAS CAN NOT BE CREATED / ISSUED by any CHINESE BANK. In fact, NO BANK ( anywhere) can issue a DEMAND DRAFT in RMB !
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
The person who told you that was braindead. Again, the RMB is not a freely convertible currency and no bank in America -- even Bank of China, New York, can clear an RMB negotiable instrument. Ever. I suspect the person you spoke with isn't aware exactly the issues with Chinese currency and just told you their standard policy for freely convertible currencies.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
gdbill
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
True.
I might add that a check can be issued which is payable in Hong Kong in RMB, but that would do Leor no good.
A demand draft is virtually just another name for cashier's check (there are slight differences). While I wouldn
't go so far as to say no bank in China can issue an RMB cashier's check, you are absolutely correct in that negotiable instrument would be worthless once outside of China.
Not only is there a problem with RMB not being a freely convertible currency, but the act of negotiating the RMB item and trying to obtain US$ would be impossible with current currency restrictions.
"Truth is not a commodity in short supply: The problem is, there's very little demand for it." -- ???
admirerdr
Re: monthly international bank transfer inquiry
COC and PO are Bankers jargon for a Bank's payment order drawn on itself (in local currency)- my apologies !
I did not say that "no bank in China can issue a RMB cashier's check" - what I meant was that "NO BANK (Chinese)can issue a DEMAND DRAFT in RMB payable OVERSEAS ( say USA /UK / Middle East ). Similarly, NO Bank ( anywhere ) can issue a DEMAND DRAFT in RMB payable at a BANK in CHINA.
For example: Lloyds Bank in UK can issue a DEMAND DRAFT in GBP drawn on Lloyds Bank Dubai UAE, whereas ICBC can not issue a DEMAND DRAFT in RMB payable at ICBC Dubai (UAE). Again, Lloyds Bank in Dubai (UAE) can issue a DD in GBP drawn on Lloyds Bank London UK, but ICBC Dubai can not issue a DD in RMB drawn on ICBC Beijing (AED - UAE currency is freely convertible and without any restrictions, whereas RMB is NOT)