I eat here regularly and have always found it to be pretty good. It's definitely not fancy, nor "real" Italian, but I much prefer Elisa's over Annie's. I think, overall, it's a bit less expensive too. My personal favorite is the gnocchi with gorgonzola cream sauce--not for the dieter but delicious if you like the gorg.
Their specials can be hit or miss, but sometimes they're quite delicious. We had a pan-seared goose liver with green apple the other day that was just awesome. And I guess any Italian restaurant review must address the pizza: Elisa's is pretty decent; not as good as The Tree but better than Annie's. Delivery is nice, too.
Of course, this is just my opinion.