2010 Mar 22 Diners Beware: Toxic Chopsticks and Recycled Oil
One of the most disturbing aspects of living in contemporary China is the seemingly endless stream of food safety bad news stories. The past week has seen some real doozies even by China standards, with a CCTV investigative report claiming many disposable chopsticks are highly toxic, and allegations that the use of oil dredged from drains is rampant in Chinese restaurants.
The CCTV report on the manufacturing of disposable chopsticks went to air last Monday (March 15), featuring images of workers happily walking over piles of the utensils tossed on factory floors and dogs sniffing around work areas.
More disturbing were the allegations summarized in a Global Times report last Friday (March 19): “Toxic chemicals including sulfur, hydrogen peroxide and paraffin are believed to be used to keep disposable chopsticks white and smooth, and also as an insect repellent, according to a CCTV program on March 15. Hydrogen peroxide is a powerful oxidizer used as a rocket propellant, among its many other industrial applications.”
The Global Times report also quotes Dong Jinshi of the Kaifa Environment Technology Consultation Center talking about disposable chopsticks: "Eighty percent of these things are not safe… and when you consider the packaging, it is only worse. Some plastic sleeves are made of garbage plastic.”
Then there were the reports that waste oil sourced from drains commonly finds its way back into restaurant kitchens. The Global Times reported this morning: “Huang Fenghong, deputy director of the Oil Crops Research Institute at the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, told the Global Times that, after seven years of field research, his research team has concluded that the use of recycled oil is rampant in some areas, especially where cash-strapped migrant workers and students are major diners. Recycled cooking oil, dubbed ‘drainage oil,’ is refined from discarded kitchen waste and reused in the preparation of meals at restaurants and canteens. ‘The use of drainage oil will put the public's health in peril because it may contain heavy metal, waste antibiotics or aflatoxins, a highly toxic substance that could cause cancer,’ he said.”
The report continues: “He Dongping, a nutrition professor at central China's Wuhan Polytechnic University and a member of Huang's team, told the China Youth Daily on Thursday that people in China consume about 2 to 3 million tons of drainage oil a year. ‘China consumes about 22.5 million tons of cooking oil annually, which means that one in 10 meals in the country may be cooked with illegal cooking oil,’ the newspaper quoted him as saying.”
China Daily was more blunt: “Read this before you eat at Chinese restaurants next time. Every year, two to three million tons of swill-cooked dirty oil, soaked with poisonous carcinogens have sneaked back to our dining tables through an underground muck-money network so rampant that it's an open secret in the industry, the China Youth Daily reported Wednesday…. According to an undercover investigation in Wuhan by nine senior students of professor He, the conspiracy starts at night when swill-fishers hollow out the stinking hogwash from urban sewages, followed by filtrating, heating, subsiding, dividing, and then in the morning comes out the clear-looking ‘edible’ oil for unwitting customers.”
China Hush has translated a post that appeared on SINA in the wake of these allegations, supposedly written by an anonymous chef. The poster claims that “cases of fishing sewer waste oil are fewer now,” but sourcing oil from drains is still common practice.
The anonymous poster writes: “Where does it flow to after the drainage oil is collected? Of course the dinner table!... Drainage oil processing is simple: put it in a huge pot and heat it up, then add some chemicals, the residues and impurities in the waste oil are separated and sink to the bottom of the pot. The upper layer clear oil looks no different than the normal oil if just looking at it. The price for this oil is only 3 yuan per kg, and the normal edible oil costs 9 yuan per kg. The drainage oil is usually used by fast food restaurants, food stalls, street food stands and including some companies’ in-house cafeterias.”
So, to summarize: it appears the food supply and our milk are contaminated, the oil our food is cooked is often sourced from drains or sewers, and most of the chopsticks we eat with are highly toxic.
Bon appetite!

You might also be interested in :
McNugget Additives: Would You Like Nausea and Delirium With That?

Another day, another report on questionable additives in Chinese food. According to a CNN report, McDonald’s China processes chicken nuggets with two chemicals that are more commonly found in Silly Putty.
Slow Off the Press: News You Might Have Missed
Take a break from the return of the work week with a look at what’s been going on in Beijing. What better way to procrastinate than with odd and interesting news and videos?Food Scandals Exploding Throughout China

Food scandals are so common in China that they no longer offer shock or surprise to anyone that’s been here for any length of time. To wake everyone up from that dull slumber Chinese farmers have truly outdone themselves this time – exploding watermelons. Add to that drugged fish and counterfeit duck to round out the latest list to watch what you eat.
All Mapped Out: China launches its own online map service
A report this week in the China Daily (spotted via the English People's Daily website) says officials with the State Bureau of Surveying and Mapping have announced “more than 100 domestic and overseas companies that provide online mapping services have received licenses to continue doing business in China, while another 100 [are] still applying for a license.”Nokia’s Alliance Internet Services (a joint venture between the Finnish handset maker and a Shanghai company) was among those on the list of approved companies, but mention of Google’s online mapping service was conspicuously absent from the article, which could spell bad news for the online giant and its users in China -- when asked about Google’s status, officials reportedly sidestepped the question, merely stating “China's Internet market is open and free and those who conduct online mapping services in China should abide by Chinese law.”
Hot Links - Stolen iTunes, Segways, and a China-free Christmas

Global Times: Hacked iTunes accounts sold online
Yes, we all know China is the world's virtual home for some 90% of all global viruses, and a classic breeding ground for hackers. If you thought iTunes was safe think again. Apparently, there is plenty to be made in account stealing. For a mere 200 yuan, an Internet user in China can purchase up to $200 worth of digital products from Apple's vast music, movie and applications vault. This reminds us once more to be vigilant about our online security.





simmi_mehra
Re: Diners Beware: Toxic Chopsticks and Recycled Oil
This is shocking

bobby_liu
Re: Diners Beware: Toxic Chopsticks and Recycled Oil
spettro9
Re: Diners Beware: Toxic Chopsticks and Recycled Oil
i already wanted to wrap things up here in China.
now i'm reminded that it's imperative.
What China really needs:
- Bill Nye, "the Science Guy", to come teach them basic Science.
- Jared Diamond, Dan Brown, and Spencer Wells to teach them about world/human history.
- MLK and Gandhi and Einstein to teach them about what being human means.
oskarbull
Re: Diners Beware: Toxic Chopsticks and Recycled Oil
Are no one questioning the lack of facts in these articles.
If 1 in 10 meals contain this oil, why is there no quotes like "In the food we tested, we found traces of etc. etc"?
Where are these statistics from? How are they not safe? Isn't recycled plastic garbage plastic? I have so many questions!
Some people claim to be under the impression that some of the articles published in China may be based on some rumors which are believed to be less reliable than facts.
danedwards
Re: Diners Beware: Toxic Chopsticks and Recycled Oil
Hi oskarbull,
It's true that reports in the Chinese press are often vague on sources etc.
However, regarding your question: "Why is there no quotes like 'In the food we tested, we found traces of etc. etc'?"
If you read the post more carefully you will find this quote from a Global Times article:
“Huang Fenghong, deputy director of the Oil Crops Research Institute at the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, told the Global Times that, after seven years of field research, his research team has concluded that the use of recycled oil is rampant in some areas, especially where cash-strapped migrant workers and students are major diners."
In other words, the claims about drainage oil are based on research by the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences. Given the Academy's affiliations with the state, it seems unlikely they'd just make this stuff up.
As for the reports on chopsticks, a fluent Chinese speaker would be better able to detail what was said in the CCTV report. But I saw the report when it went to air, and the images of the grossly unhygienic conditions in the factories making these things alone were pretty worrying, even before you consider the allegations about the chemicals used in the chopsticks' production.
You're right to be skeptical about everything you read and hear, but I think there have been enough reports by different organizations, including many inside China, to point to some very serious problems with food safety and the production of food-related products inside the PRC.
Cheers,
Dan Edwards
Register and post your own events on the beijinger website.
lucreziab
Re: Diners Beware: Toxic Chopsticks and Recycled Oil
This is why I just eat at home these days.