Beat That Commute: Cycling Suicide or Subway Sardines?

Over the past two years (and probably since all eternity) Beijing’s inhabitants have had the longest commutes of all of China. Oddly, last year’s 50 minutes was somehow ten minutes less than the year before. However, China Daily recently posted an article on a new study that quotes a Beijinger’s average commute at 1 hour and 20 minutes. To measure ourselves against the rest of Beijing we did a little in-house survey. Here’s what we figured out

On average it takes the Editorial team 34.8 min to get to work. That is almost fifty minutes less than the city average. Assuming that we're not just incredibly lucky we thought that there must be a reason for this. Could it be because 71% of us travel by bike?

Cycling Pros and Cons

  • PRO - speed
  • PRO - low cost (once you have a bike)
  • PRO - exercise without having to go to the gym
  • PRO - health (I’d dispute this one because of pollution and the risk of imminent death).
  • CON - injury or death by traffic accident or pollution

The majority of the rest of the team claimed to take the subway to work. There was the odd murmur of walking when the weather is nice and taking the bus. No one was willing to admit to cabbing in everyday (although we suspect that it happens), none of us are paid well enough to afford a driver and no one is confident enough to get a Segway. Even still, those getting the subway seem to be doing something right too.

Subway Pros and Cons

  • PRO - speed over a long distance
  • PRO - time to read/play Angry Birds
  • CON - it's so damn crowded
  • CON - inconvenient locations of subway stations

We respect your personal choices when commuting (although clearly, bicycles win) Here are some survival tips for those eschewing cabs and cars.

Cycling Tips:

  • Common sense. Keep your eyes and ears open for crazy drivers, don't listen to music
  • Keep your most expensive items on your body and try not to show off that you have them
  • Get an ugly bike so it doesn't get stolen
  • Be aware of the “turning right is at all times allowed rule” always watch out for those cars
  • Get a face mask unless you have hidden ambitions to become the next Tom Waits

Subway Tips:

  • Get on the subway near the stairs so you don't have to fight to get to the stairs faster when you get off
  • Know which stop the door closes and doesn't open for several stops so you can lean on it longer
  • The joint of the train is the coolest spot in summer
  • If you want a seat on the train follow these simple instructions

Good luck shaving time of that commute.

Photo: Sina & The Age

Comments

New comments are displayed first.

I'm on your side and ride my bike to work as well, I just can't imagine rolling in from Wudaokou or wherever.
But let's do it scientifically and have a series of subway vs. bicycle races. We can measure heart-rate and stress along the way too. Maybe we can even publish a paper, it'll be great.

I used to bike to work, Hepingli area to Jingshan Park area--a leisurely 20 minutes. Then my company moved to Weigongcun--and my nice 20 minute commute turned into 45 minutes. 45 minutes if I was lucky. No more nice leisurely commute--I had to fly along those roads, would arrive hot and gross--and then had to sit at my desk for the next 8 hours. (And moving closer to work wasn't a great option, for a number of reasons.)

By the time I was on my 6th bike and developing some serious breathing problems, I started to wonder whether this was really worth it. (1) I'd "lost" five bikes, no matter how many locks I put on them or where I locked them. One was stolen from outside my apartment door in the five minutes I ran inside to get something--despite being locked to the window grate with three locks. (2) I was in a foul mood nearly every day when I got to work, after being run down/cut off/screamed at by car drivers. (3) I arrived sweaty and stinky, with no way to get clean for the next eight hours at work, which did not contribute to my already foul mood. Perfume/body spray resulted in a migraine and funny looks/comments from Chinese colleagues. (4) I was getting severe colds or flus every winter that I just couldn't shake. In 2005, I caught a cold in October, and it lasted til April of the next year. (5) Even when I didn't have a cold, I still had serious lung problems, despite my heavy duty air cleaner at home; the lovely hack-and-spit of the long-term Beijing resident; and a persistent cough I couldn't shake. That cough would occasionally turn into extended coughing fits that terrified my colleagues; you can imagine how well that went over during SARS and the various flu scares in later years.

So after 4 years of biking around Beijing, I decided it wasn't worth it. I gave away my (pink) bike to a (male) Chinese friend, and went the subway route for the next five years. Five years of misery. Five years of being squeezed, crushed, poked, prodded, sneezed on, coughed on, stared at and glared at. Five years of silently repeating "Thou shalt not kill" as I did battle with the hordes an hour every morning and an hour every evening. There were a few bright spots: the occasional old man who would make sure I got his seat when his stop came up; the little old ladies who would admire my crocheting and discuss their own projects; a friendly girl or two who would make room for me to move to the middle of the car. But on the whole, the subway at rush hour is misery, and after five years, I decided that if I didn't find some alternate form of transportation, I might do someone some serious injury.

So last year I headed down to the shop near my apartment and got myself an electric scooter (and then bought a serious lock from the States to avoid theft and a good face mask from Singapore to deal with the pollution). Yes, I look like an idiot. But the commute is down to 25-30 minutes, and I'm no longer in danger of committing a felony.

Doubt wisely; in strange way / To stand inquiring right is not to stray; / To sleep, or run wrong, is. (Donne, Satire III)

Getting to work on the subway takes me 50 or so minutes, whereas it's only 25-30 minutes on my bike (depending on traffic) Smile

Xiaohuoshan,
34 minutes of cycling can get you a long way - much further than the same 34 minutes of subway commute might take you when you factor in getting to the subway, going through security, getting to the platform, waiting for a train, taking the train, getting out of the station, and then getting to the office.

Of course, it depends on how far you have to travel to get to work. For longer journeys a subway's likely the best way but if it's only a handful of stops then a bike might cut down your commute.

Jonathan White, Managing Editor the Beijinger/TheBeijinger.com

Beijing is a massive city and not everybody has the luxury of living downtown in a rented apartment next to the office. Your 34 minutes means that some poor sucker has a 2+ hour commute ahead of them. I don't see how a bike is going to cut that time down.